The Pros and Cons of Choosing a Public Family Tree vs. a Private Family Tree
Before rushing into posting your family tree online, I caution you to step back and take a careful look at the options available. Depending on the website, you choose for posting your tree there are often options to consider. The largest one is whether you want your tree to be viewed by all (public) or would you like to retain control of who can view your tree (private).
For some historians they know exactly what they want, but for others the choice can be disconcerting. Many have personal reasons for their choices, and after hearing many opinions on the subject, here are a few pros and cons as to why some choose one over the other.
Public Family Trees
Pro: You allow everyone to see your tree, opening up endless opportunities to meet distance cousins.
Con: You allow everyone to see your tree, opening up endless opportunities for distant cousins to lift your information without making a personal connection with you.
Pro: You wish to enjoy the benefits of other researcher’s public trees then you should share as well.
Con: Not everyone’s tree is sourced and cited, some are working trees and not all information can be deemed credible. Not all trees are created equal.
Pro: You can share valuable information with others that they would not have obtained without you.
Con: You have invested long hours and money to share valuable information with those who have done little legwork for the reward.
Pro: Public trees provide quick and easy access to information that may otherwise take years to uncover.
Con: Public trees have turned genealogy into a lazy man’s hobby.
Private Family Trees
Pro: You can control who sees your information and what information you wish to release to them.
Con: Many distant cousins may feel intimidated by your private status and not contact you.
Pro: You can keep a public profile despite having a private tree, making yourself a little more accessible to those who wish to contact you.
Con: You may have to deal with many emails since others cannot view your tree and move on if they do not see what they are looking for.
Pro: Personal information on your living relatives is better protected in a private tree.
Con: Many fear hackers can still access this information and it is not safe, while some public trees also provide the same protection on living a relative’s information.
Pro: A private tree will weed out the casual researchers and only the serious connections will attempt to contact you.
Con: A private tree may weed out a casual researcher that could hold some valuable information on your family tree.
Pro: You don’t wish to spread unsourced information that may exist in your tree. You have control.
Con: Too much control may make feel like you are limiting yourself to possible new connections and new information.
Pro: You can control other researchers from spreading inaccurate information.
Con: You are not responsible for other researcher’s trees.
Pro: You have paid for this information in hard work, long hours and money why should you share it.
Con: You fear becoming too territorial over your information, sharing is important in genealogy.
Pro: You don’t want the Mormons to baptize your dead ancestors.
Con: They given so much to the genealogy community, genealogists should give back.
There are as many reasons as there are people on why or why not to choose a public tree vs. a private tree. However, one should carefully think through the options before jumping in. There are many family historians out there with stories to tell from both sides of the fence, listen up and then make the decision that you feel best suits your needs.
Related Reading: Is There Chaos Online?